Saturday, October 20, 2007

Outside Reading Week Five







I am finally done with my outside reading book and I am currently working ony my multi flow map for our final assessment. It seems like one of these maps would be easy but it is a lot harder than I thought going into it. Especially with the whole needing quotes to support what we are arguing. We have to find a struggle in the plot and the causes and effects of it. As in most cases, there is morew than one conflict in this book. Some of them are short lived, some are small, and some are in moments of extreme emotion but then soon fade away. But I need to ask myself, which one is the longest lasting in the book, that will never really be compltetely solved or vanish forever?


The conflict that I see as the most ocurring and visible is the conflict between what Edie believes and how Graceanne acts. Edie has had hard times in her life and so has Graceanne, but instead of coming together to work through it, they push against each other in order to relieve the pain. Graceanne is not allowed to make any mistakes, which should naturally be a part of her childhood. We usually say "you learn from your mistakes", but the only thing she learns is that if she does anything wrong she will be beaten. They already have conflicting personalities, but Edie's extreme expectations for near perfection are hard enforce on Graceanne, who longs for freedom. She is not as harsh on Charlie or Kentucky, which is shown when she lets Kentucky leave and quickly forgives Charlie for any little thing he does wrong. This effects the family and Graceanne in many ways. The whole family becomes slightly afraid of Edie, who I believe is not a scary person, but just wants control in her life. The whole town is slightly suspicious throughout the whole book, but the kids never tell anyone in fear of breaking Edie's trust and making her more mad. Graceanne obviously is effected the most. Of course with the temporary effects of being beaten up, but she also tries to find comfort in others and be out of the house as much as possible. I think that struggle is always a good way to analyze a book, because it is always there and it allows you to see more into the characters you are reading about.

No comments: